Can you back this up with any science? Not doubting you but if it's true it has ramifications for those growing larger plants.i gave it a lot of thought......it will be available for a few months. difference is, clones do not yield the same. they don't have the established root system to grow a large plant unless you grow them a very long time and their structure can be a bit crazy when grown out. i may get seeds at some point, but they are pricey too to do a whole room full.
I've also read similar, but don't have any direct experience outdoors where I imagine this would really come into play. indoors, and depending on the method of grow, i've managed to get some very respectably sized plants that started out as clones within reasonable veg times.Roots.....science, no, not really. But it's out there somewhere as i've seen numerous breeders discuss it. But 35+ years of growing both have shown me the light.
Clones do not have the root system to support a large plant, as they do not have a main tap root like a plant from seed. You can get them to grow big, but it will be a long time in veg. With seeds, 100-110 days you get a large plant and large yield.
Further, I think clones grow roots closer to the surface. The tap root off a seed grows down deep, straight down.
Anyone else want to comment on this, help a brother out. lol
some day i'll do a side by side and put that to the test. i've always found the few weeks of lag time when starting from seed to be fairly prohibitive whereas i can get clones rooted in as little as seven days and right into veg. then again there's also the issue of genetics and vitality of the seed. some seeds are more vigorous than others, but with a carefully chosen cultivar and a strong healthy mom, the clones are almost guaranteed to be just as vigorous as the mother stock.it depends what you count as reasonable..........you will NOT have the same size plant growing from seed vs. clone, in the same time frame.
@Moe.Redit depends what you count as reasonable..........you will NOT have the same size plant growing from seed vs. clone, in the same time frame.
SSHZ I have noticed some pretty big differences in growth of clones versus from seeds. I have been running clones for so long I did really notice it until I stated looking for some new cultivars. First off seeds can take a ton of light pretty much from day one. I know you run your lights at full capacity from day one. A clone IMO just cannot handle that kind of light, maybe 20 percent once rooted. I believe it takes a clone much longer to develop the root system required for high PPFD. I find myself not able to get a clone to accept 100 percent of the light from the same light you are running until the clone is about 40 days old. I try to have the lights at 100 percent no later than the end of week 1 of flower. Once the clones are able to handle ( the root system) the light they really take off. I ran soil before and I further believe clones in soil can handle more light quicker than in hydro.Roots.....science, no, not really. But it's out there somewhere as i've seen numerous breeders discuss it. But 35+ years of growing both have shown me the light.
Clones do not have the root system to support a large plant, as they do not have a main tap root like a plant from seed. You can get them to grow big, but it will be a long time in veg. With seeds, 100-110 days you get a large plant and large yield.
Further, I think clones grow roots closer to the surface. The tap root off a seed grows down deep, straight down.
Anyone else want to comment on this, help a brother out. lol
Interesting take. Would leave to see how the biology works on this.There you go.........from the man himself.
i look at it this way- the tap root from seed i'd guess is the best at absorbing moisture in the medium. And the longer the tap root, the more smaller roots it's able to out out. Since clones do not have one, they are lacking in roots and their ability to absorb enough to handle a high respiration rate under 100% lighting. i think the tap root also goes a long way to support the overall plant and helps large plants stay upright.
When i grew from clones, i always had a single mother, which was a clone at one time. i've had a single mother give me over 1000 clones in her life. when she became too root bound, i'd turn one of her clones into a new mother. The clones took months to develop into a large size. i thought the key advantage of clones was they take on the mothers age. So a clone from a mother 1 year old is already one year old, and will flower earlier than a plant from seed. But then the consideration is having it large enough before flowering, so the yield is what you are looking for.
Is that Tarzan I see swinging through that jungle?110 days in veg is almost 16 weeks
Here's what 7 weeks looks like in my system View attachment 20175
A few years ago you commented to me about maximizing my yield if i grew your style. I agree, but its not just about yield.What a waste of space........i understand plant limits some of us live under but still...........
Ok that makes senseSmoke.......no, 100-110 days from sprout to harvest.
He ain't doing it commercial so he doesn't need to maximize floor space for better yields.What a waste of space........i understand plant limits some of us live under but still...........
Wasn't taken that way at all, was just out in the garage me and a bowl of hash, thinking "i like my rooms, that's why they call them "roomsI speak purely from a commercial point of view.......... it was not a knock on his plants mind you. When I see space in a grow room that you can drive a car thru, I see dollar bills flying out the window. It’s just my approach. No disrespect intended..........
I know the feeling. Whenever I pass by a vacant warehouse my first thought is "I wonder how much power they got in there?"I speak purely from a commercial point of view.......... it was not a knock on his plants mind you. When I see space in a grow room that you can drive a car thru, I see dollar bills flying out the window. It’s just my approach. No disrespect intended..........
one clone I had taken early in flower I’d done in previous grows took ages to reveg and had a heap of branches when it was only 7’’ tall . cut the ones I didn’t want and bent 8 out away from ea other.stayed very short and took up fuckall room but harvested between 4-5 ounces.I thought to myself straight away if I could monstercrop all the time I reckon I could get way more plants in my room like you do sshz. but they take friggen ages lol .I only have 2-3 monster cropped ,the other taken before flower..was going to show ya a pic of the one I done a yr or so ago but my threads have been banished from the big sook farm..Roots.....science, no, not really. But it's out there somewhere as i've seen numerous breeders discuss it. But 35+ years of growing both have shown me the light.
Clones do not have the root system to support a large plant, as they do not have a main tap root like a plant from seed. You can get them to grow big, but it will be a long time in veg. With seeds, 100-110 days you get a large plant and large yield.
Further, I think clones grow roots closer to the surface. The tap root off a seed grows down deep, straight down.
Anyone else want to comment on this, help a brother out. lol
Those gavita leds keep them much more stout!You guys will like this.....lol
Here's my Zsweet Inzanity grow from 2018, under 2 HPS in a different room. i didn't top, and i didn't defoliate or lolipop. This is at 3 weeks, 2 days further along than my current grow. Notice any differences? lol
View attachment 20459
I have never ran clones side by side either but I understand when the tap root hits the bottom of a container it will trigger flower stage. My 2 cents SSgrowerRoots.....science, no, not really. But it's out there somewhere as i've seen numerous breeders discuss it. But 35+ years of growing both have shown me the light.
Clones do not have the root system to support a large plant, as they do not have a main tap root like a plant from seed. You can get them to grow big, but it will be a long time in veg. With seeds, 100-110 days you get a large plant and large yield.
Further, I think clones grow roots closer to the surface. The tap root off a seed grows down deep, straight down.
Anyone else want to comment on this, help a brother out. lol
Sometimes when growing perpetual fir my own use variety is the goal not quantity I’ve pulled as little as a 1/2 lb out a 5x5 before ! - on the flip side nice work sshz you got ur grows dialed been running like that for a minute or two I would assume ! LolI speak purely from a commercial point of view.......... it was not a knock on his plants mind you. When I see space in a grow room that you can drive a car thru, I see dollar bills flying out the window. It’s just my approach. No disrespect intended..........